The somme was an imperative offensive to the british war effort to prevent a french collapse at verdun and break the deadlock in europe it totaled a devastating 420,000 casualties to 620,000 casualties which was a total of 21%-31% of the total british casualties in the great war in a relatively short period of time (less than 5 months)[2. He was remembered and reviled as a butcher, a donkey, a dunderhead this reversal of opinion owed much to lloyd george's war memoirs, but more to revulsion at the horror of war and the terrible cost of haig's battles. Does general haig deserve to be remembered as 'the butcher of the somme'notes for teachers / candidatesyour assignment should start with an introductionhere you should briefly outline the history of the battle of the sommeyou should also refer to the different ways that people have interpreted haig' rolein the battle of the sommethis. The war continued on, and eventually, it ended with haig succeeding in capturing verdun and drove the germans off french soil however, there were heavy war casualties, and from then on, general douglas haig was either regarded as a victorious war winner by some or a ruthless butcher by others. After his death some people blamed haig for the terrible loss of soldiers in the war they thought he was a ruthless and uncaring general and some even called him 'the butcher of the somme.
When britain declared war on germany on aug 4, 1914, haig led the 1st army corps into northern france to drive the germans off french soil it was a small, inexperienced citizens' army. Douglas haig quotes british - soldier june 19 , 1861 - january 28 , 1928 the idea that a war can be won by standing on the defensive and waiting for the enemy to attack is a dangerous fallacy, which owes its inception to the desire to evade the price of victory. Sir douglas haig is known in history under the title of the 'butcher of the somme' due to the significant number of casualties in the battle of the somme, which he caused as a result of being the field marshal that led the troops to war.
Douglas haig: world war i's worst general sir douglas haig, chief of staff of the british expeditionary force (bef) was the architect of the greatest tragedyof the british national military history in world war i. Does haig deserve his nickname the butcher of the somme feild marshall haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of december 1915, he was fifty-four at the time and he had had a very succesful military career haig decided to attack the germans at the river somme in 1916 to attract german. Field marshal douglas haig was a british senior officer during world war 1 he commanded the british expeditionary force from 1915 to the end of the war we will write a custom essay sample on haig: butcher of the somme specifically for you. The great war - week by week 100 years later s3 • e40 douglas haig's fantasies drown in mud i the great war week 115 - duration: 10:34 the great war 192,810 views.
We will write a custom essay sample on the first world war - field marshall haig: the butcher of the somme specifically for you for only $1638 $139/page order now. Deftly sidestepping caricatures of haig as either a callous, incompetent butcher or as a clear-sighted, imperturbable great captain, harris offers a nuanced picture of a complex personality in hopeless times. Was haig a butcher or war winner 3538 words | 15 pages assessment- interpretations of haig (the battle of the sommes was a notorious event that occurred in the time frame of world war i, between france and england on one side, while on the other side, germany. Answer sir douglas haig as a commander can easily be called a butcher any battle in any war can be called a butchery and nameless battles in the history of man are right ly or wrongly given. Haig and his men had very different views of how the war was going this is summed up in two quotes haig said, the work of our artillery is wholly admirable-, this evidently shows that haig is happy with the performance of his soldiers and that they are doing well in the battle of the somme.
Just as ulysses grant of the american civil war was adamant that the confederacy lived and died with lee's army of northern virginia, so to in the first world war was haig adamant that the central powers lived and died with the fortunes of germany. Haig was faced with the problem that there did not exist at that time any weapon which could win the war without the loss of many lives this is the view that most serious historians take of the. Great commanders douglas haig: the chief field marshal sir douglas haig commanded the british army when it achieved arguably its greatest victories, those over the germans on the western front during the first world war (1914-18. Douglas haig, britain's first world war commander-in-chief from december 1915 to the end of the war, is remembered as the archetypal 'donkey' leading 'lions' to their death by the thousands but, a century on, is this a fair judgement born in edinburgh, 19 june 1861, douglas haig was the. The negative reputation of field marshal douglas haig, the commander of british forces on the western front during world war one, rests to a large degree on his performance at the somme.
Douglas haig and the first world war fromdecember1915untilthearmisticeofnovember1918,sirdouglas haig was commander-in-chief of the largest army his country had ever. General douglas haig has been blamed for the slaughter of thousands of men who were under his control in world war one the battle of the somme was one of the worst fights in the entire war and 55,000 british soldiers died in the first day alone. Source d is by william brooks who was a private in the british army during world war 1 haig's nickname was the butcher he'd think nothing of sending thousands of.
Douglas haig is usually the centre of the lions vs donkeys debate were the british soldiers lions led by donkeys during world war 1 douglas haig, the father of the battle of the somme, is. Evaluate: was general haig the 'butcher of the somme skills: cause, however, in the immediate aftermath of the first world war, haig was seen as a hero he was. Historians of past and present argue about whether haig alone was responsible for so many casualties john laffin wrote his book, ' british butchers and bunglers of world war one', in 1996 and was strongly against haig as a commander.